The summer is long gone, and school districts are dealing with a new school year (including inevitable early snafus). However, even while attending to their usual duties, school officials cannot forget about compliance with Connecticut’s Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and requests for records. The following true story shows how one can straddle two worlds: 1) a school employee’s “typical” duties; and 2) FOIA compliance.
First, The General FOIA Rule. Public records must generally be accessible and made available to persons making requests to inspect them “promptly” during regular business hours. Whether an agency’s compliance with a FOIA request was in fact “prompt” will be determined by Connecticut’s Freedom of Information Commission (FOIC) on a case-by-case basis, based upon (among other things) the nature/volume of the request, the time and personnel required to comply with a request, and the time constraints under which the agency must complete its other work.
The FOIC has noted that while the FOIA does not explicitly authorize an agency to require a person to make an appointment to inspect public records,
If an agency politely explains to a person seeking access to records why immediate compliance is not possible, that person will most likely understand and appreciate the agency’s obligation to balance its duties as custodian of public records with its other duties. … In the final analysis, it is the Commission’s opinion that this rule of reason and courtesy, if implemented, should eliminate the vast majority of potential conflicts between a citizen’s right to timely access to public records and an agency’s duty to comply while processing other important business.
In the Matter of a Request for Declaratory Ruling, Third Taxing District of the City of Norwalk, Applicant, Advisory Opinion #51 (January 11, 1982).
School Opening Issues and a FOIA request (Yes, a True Story). In one situation, a citizen came to a school district’s central office at the end of the second day of school, and asked to inspect specific records. The district asserted that it was unable to attend to the request at that time because it was addressing urgent transportation matters that had arisen due to redistricting and the implementation of several programs. Indeed, at the moment of the request to inspect records, the district was simultaneously trying to locate a missing student who was not on his assigned bus and fielding many calls from anxious parents whose children were on buses that had been extremely late or overcrowded on the previous day. It goes without saying that this was a situation where all school personnel were involved in dealing with these issues, with some working several hours past the end of their regular workday. In addition to the chaos at the time of the request, the district’s finance director believed that 1) the records sought would need to be redacted to withhold confidential student information, 2) some time and personnel would need to be devoted to compliance with the request, and 3) this could not be done immediately.
The finance director informed the requester that he would be unable to have immediate access to the records sought, but the district would work on it the next day when the busing issues calmed down. The requester began to argue and interrupted the finance director’s phone call with the superintendent about the busing situation; the requester even insisted that the finance director read aloud certain passages of the FOIA in an attempt to convince him to provide immediate access to the records. The finance director insisted that the requester leave and told him that he would call the police if he did not do so. The finance director then had a brief conversation with the requester about why none of the personnel could respond to his request at that time, and the requester then left.
The FOIC found that the school district did not violate the FOIA when it did not permit the requester to inspect immediately the records that he requested. The FOIC noted that the district attempted to comply with the request in a timely manner and without undue delay, in the context of other immediate and pressing business.
Takeaways (Besides “Beware of School Transportation Changes”). Sometimes, common sense prevails. The above situation was a textbook example of a public official faithfully executing all of their duties. The FOIC has noted that complying with FOIA requests is not a “second class duty” but rather is a “primary duty” for public officials, that is “as much a part of their mission as their other major functions” and “should take precedence over routine work that has no immediate or pressing deadline.” Nothing in the FOIA permits an agency to “de-prioritize” or ignore this important job duty. However, FOIA compliance is not the sole duty of public officials. Nothing in the FOIA requires public officials to interrupt their other legitimate work in order to immediately fulfill FOIA requests, since “prompt access” does not mean immediate access, and a public agency may have other priority projects that require more immediate attention.
Please note: This post was adapted from an article written by the author for the September 2026 edition of the CABE Journal; it is republished here with permission.
This blog/web site presents general information only. The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice, and you should not consider or rely on it as such. You should consult an attorney for individual advice regarding your own situation. This website is not an offer to represent you. You should not act, or refrain from acting, based upon any information at this website. Neither our presentation of such information nor your receipt of it creates nor will create an attorney-client relationship with any reader of this blog. Any links from another site to the blog are beyond the control of Pullman & Comley, LLC and do not convey their approval, support or any relationship to any site or organization. Any description of a result obtained for a client in the past is not intended to be, and is not, a guarantee or promise the firm can or will achieve a similar outcome.
About Our School Law Blog
Alerts, commentary, and insights from the attorneys of Pullman & Comley’s School Law practice on federal and Connecticut law as it pertains to educational institutions, whether those institutions be public school districts, private K-12 schools, or post-secondary colleges and universities.
