Anti-Raiding Agreements Can Cause Big Trouble For Employers

Recent developments in two California lawsuits confirm that employers take big risks if they agree with competitors not to recruit each other’s employees.  Apple, Google, eBay, Intuit, and other large technology companies face antitrust claims from both the U.S. Justice Department and employees arising from “handshake agreements” that may have been intended to call a truce in the war for talent, but that the plaintiffs allege drove down salaries and benefits.

About a year ago, the Justice Department and the State of California sued eBay, alleging that Meg Whitman, formerly CEO of EBay, and Scott Cook, chairman at Intuit, had agreed not to recruit or hire each other’s employees.  Intuit had settled a Justice Department case over hiring practices in 2010, and wasn’t named as a defendant.  eBay moved to dismiss both cases, but in September of this year, the U.S. District Court denied eBay’s motion as to the Justice Department’s case, finding that “the United States has plausibly alleged an actionable agreement between the two companies.”  Read the opinion here.  The court dismissed California’s case, but gave the state leave to refile.  Read the opinion here.

Meanwhile, in 2011 several software engineers brought cases in California state court against seven large technology companies (including Intuit, but not EBay), claiming that anti-raiding agreements among the firms drove down wages.  Defendants removed the actions to federal court, where they were consolidated, and the plaintiffs sought class certification.  The court initially denied their motion, but gave the plaintiffs leave to amend their complaint.  The plaintiffs then filed a Supplemental Motion for Class Certification addressed to the specific concerns the court had raised, which related primarily to the definition of the class and whether common issues would predominate.  (While the Supplemental Motion was pending, the  plaintiffs reached settlements with Intuit, Pixar, and Lucasfilm, but the case continued against Adobe, Apple, Google, and Intel.)  The court granted class certification on October 24, 2013.  Read the opinion HERE.

The defendants in both of these cases now face both significant damages exposure and huge litigation costs.  Even smaller employers unlikely to face claims under federal antitrust laws should take heed; claims may also be brought under state laws, such as the Connecticut Unfair Trade Practices Act and the Connecticut Antitrust Act, as well as the common law of unfair competition.  In Connecticut (unlike in California), courts will enforce reasonable non-competition and non-solicitation agreements between employers and employees, but employers would be well-advised not to enter into anti-raiding agreements with competitors.

This blog/web site presents general information only. The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice, and you should not consider or rely on it as such. You should consult an attorney for individual advice regarding your own situation. This website is not an offer to represent you. You should not act, or refrain from acting, based upon any information at this website. Neither our presentation of such information nor your receipt of it creates nor will create an attorney-client relationship with any reader of this blog. Any links from another site to the blog are beyond the control of Pullman & Comley, LLC and do not convey their approval, support or any relationship to any site or organization. Any description of a result obtained for a client in the past is not intended to be, and is not, a guarantee or promise the firm can or will achieve a similar outcome.

Subscribe to Updates

About Our Labor, Employment and Employee Benefits Law Blog

Alerts, commentary, and insights from the attorneys of Pullman & Comley’s Labor, Employment Law and Employee Benefits practice on such workplace topics as labor and employment law, counseling and training, litigation, immigration law and union issues, as well as employee benefits and ERISA matters.

Other Blogs by Pullman & Comley

Connecticut Health Law Blog

Education Law Notes

For What It May Be Worth

Recent Posts


Jump to Page